More on Bret Weinstein’s evolutionary distorting mirror

Posted on 08/12/2023 by Jon Garvey

Yesterday I critiqued Bret Weinstein’s proposed rapprochement of “science” with Christian morality, pointing out that he misunderstood the foundations of Christianity, and merely tried to replace them with an inferior, naturalistic evolutionary, narrative. In fact the problem is worse than that, because it’s not simply that his proposal hides the shaky metaphysical foundations of naturalism, but that even in materialist terms it is pseudoscientific. And that is because societal morals are demonstrably non-evolutionary. As I will now demonstrate.

Continue reading →
Posted in History, Politics and sociology, Science, Theology | Leave a comment

Bret Weinstein’s evolutionary mirror

Posted on 07/12/2023 by Jon Garvey

Bret Weinstein has been one of the good guys regarding not only COVID, but the woke phenomenon that targeted him and his wife when he was working in academia. But he’s also an evolutionary biologist, and likes to frame everything from the viewpoint of random change and natural selection. That’s useful when dealing with the micro-evolution of viruses, but less so when dealing with human values.

Continue reading →
Posted in Politics and sociology, Science, Theology | 1 Comment

Unconstitutional monarchy

Posted on 02/12/2023 by Jon Garvey

I’m not a follower of royal news, certainly not when it involves Mickey Mouse accusations of family racism, and even more when our constitutionally constrained king chooses to speak at COP28, discarding the advice he received for the last such bash, that it would be political to attend, and therefore contradictory to his role to represent the whole British people and avoid politics.

Continue reading →
Posted in History, Politics and sociology | 1 Comment

One of my occasional posts on occasionalism

Posted on 27/11/2023 by Jon Garvey

How God works in the world is often regarded (and is indeed) a deep philosophical question. But it actually matters in real life, which is why the Bible says a lot about it. Because it doesn’t do so in a systematic analytical way, but through narrative, poetry, historiography and so on, its importance is often missed by those academics who like systematics.

Continue reading →
Posted in Creation, Philosophy, Science, Theology | 6 Comments

Bad theology exposed in the tabloids

Posted on 24/11/2023 by Jon Garvey

A story in the Daily Mail today caught my attention. Essentially the piece is in the genre “human interest hit job on religious cult,” the cult in this case being “Bigoted Fundamentalist Christianity.” But I noticed it because the strapline included “Guildford County School for Girls,” in my hometown, so I wondered if the youth club that changed her life for the worse might be the one I went to.

Continue reading →
Posted in Politics and sociology, Theology | Leave a comment

A perfect jihad

Posted on 20/11/2023 by Jon Garvey

Outside observers like Ayaan Hirsi Ali and Andy Ngo (now based in London) point out the perfect storm of violence and cultural disaster now brewing across Europe, not least in England. This has been brought into focus, for those with eyes to see and ears to hear, by the crude antisemitism evident in the response in Britain to the current Middle East war, combined with the (to say the least) easy ride given to Hamas amongst our British intelligentsia. One concerning thing, to me, is how these attitudes are shared even by many in the sceptical community.

Continue reading →
Posted in History, Politics and sociology, Theology | 1 Comment

Book review: Busting Anti-Vax Myths

Posted on 19/11/2023 by Jon Garvey

I had higher than usual expectations whilst I was awaiting my free review copy of this 2022 book by Prof. Oisín MacAmadáin (Expert), not least because the author’s Dublin agent turns out to be related to me by a marriage in Queen Elizabeth I’s time. How unlikely is that? (Well, not that unlikely, since 20 generations ago both of us have 1 million ancestors, around the total population of Ireland at that time, though the fact that both ancestors were Archbishops of Armagh might change the odds a little). Still, that human connection with the author certainly warmed me to the book in advance.

Continue reading →
Posted in Medicine, Science | Leave a comment

Congregational singing is not karaoke

Posted on 16/11/2023 by Jon Garvey

One of our guys at church has just come off the sound team, and after a break of a decade is getting back into playing flute for our church band. “As I get deeper into practising,” he said, “I’m finding that a lot of the new songs aren’t written for worship, but performance.”

Continue reading →
Posted in Music, Theology | 2 Comments

The religious apologetics of naturalistic materialism

Posted on 09/11/2023 by Jon Garvey

James Tour, as many of you will know, is a noted chemist who wears his Christian faith on his sleeve, unashamedly engaging in apologetics alongside his groundbreaking research, particularly that involving nano-particles.

Continue reading →
Posted in Creation, Philosophy, Politics and sociology, Science, Theology, Theology of nature | Leave a comment

Not all hornets are US spy drones

Posted on 02/11/2023 by Jon Garvey

This one is just a “nature diary” piece, so don’t expect any geopolitical insights – or even conclusions about nature, come to that. Most years we find a wasp-nest somewhere on our two and a half acre spread, but this year it was hornets.

Continue reading →
Posted in Creation | Leave a comment