Convergence (of minds) and clades

I’m just reading a refreshingly non-controversial book of the type that first got me seriously interested in palaeontology maybe 50 years ago. It’s a new survey of Pterosaurs, by palaeontologist and skilled paleoartist Mark P Witton. I ordered it from the subject and text description, and hadn’t realised that it’s not only a comprehensive and authoritative overview of some incredibly interesting and unusual creatures, whose story has been much better understood recently, but also a gorgeously illustrated coffee-table book. It’s also excellent value for money. I’m a teenager again! Continue reading

Posted in Creation, Science, Theology | Leave a comment

When is a non-function not a non-function?

Yesterday I looked at orphan genes in the general context of providence, and cited a New Scientist article showing the increasing degree to which they are thought to arise in non-coding DNA sequences. In other words, in the proverbial “Junk DNA”. Continue reading

Posted in Creation, Science, Theology | Leave a comment

Orphan genes as Fatherly providence

The questioning of natural selection in my last two posts should be seen as a simple lack of conviction that classical Neodarwinianism is robust enough to account for, in a well-worn phrase, the origin of the species. I should emphasise again that theologically, an adequate scientific theory of evolution is perfectly compatible with the providence (ie supervision and direction) of a wise God: the denial of teleology is categorically an unscientific and metaphysical claim.

At the same time, the astonishing complexity of life, as its wonders are exponentially proving, makes some kind of teleological mechanism within biology ever more likely, if we are to avoid a high contingency theory that is unsatisfactory both scientifically and theologically. I am happy with the God of miracles, but given the mechanisms already seen at all scales of the science of life, the use of secondary causes by the Son for the unfolding purposes of the Father seems, to me, to be more plausible than a chain of pure miracles. Providence would still rule those mechanisms. Continue reading

Posted in Creation, Science, Theology | Leave a comment

A bit more on natural selection

After publishing my last post I noticed I’d downloaded from somewhere (maybe the Sanford article) a 2008 paper by Austin L Hughes about the methods that are used to detect genes that have been subject to natural selection. Continue reading

Posted in Creation, Science, Theology | 15 Comments

Putting the axe to Donar’s Oak

When Winfrith of Crediton, not many miles from the Hump’s rural seat, went to Germany and cut down a celebrated pagan sacred oak around 723 AD, the lack of any resulting thunderbolt from Thor destroyed the entire basis of pagan belief. With the tree gone, there was literally nothing left.

A couple of recent interesting papers here  and here look in detail at natural selection and question its ability to do what is claimed of it. Continue reading

Posted in Creation, Science, Theology | 5 Comments

Priorities…

No posts in over a week! That’s partly because the stuff I’ve been reading doesn’t really suggest anything of public interest . (I did a quick study on a dozen or so reasons why Matthew 16 isn’t about the Papacy, but there’s no reason to blog on that either.)

But the main reason was my preparing for a double concert with my saxophone choir yesterday – lunchtime on Lyme Regis seafront, with the echoes bouncing off the famous fossiliferous cliffs, and the ice-cream shop next door presenting us all with refreshments at the end. And in the early evening we played at a village music festival with a less peripatetic and more cultured audience sweating it out in a hall. And burgers and bitter at the pub instead of ices.

It went well, despite my logistic problems getting 3 saxes (alto, soprano and sopranino) in playing condition in the short time available, and I was proud to have four of my arrangements used. It’ll be time to hit the notation software again now for some new pieces, so I’m not sure when I’ll be back to theology and science.

Posted in Music | Leave a comment

Metaphysics drives science drives theology

I came across this 1992 symposium when following up a conversation at BioLogos in which I mentioned David L Wilcox. I’ve written about Wilcox before as a like mind in having a high (Reformed) view of God’s providence in nature, linked to at least general support for evolutionary theory (he is, after all, a population geneticist). But apart from his paper here, the whole symposium has interesting things to read. Continue reading

Posted in Creation, Science, Theology | Leave a comment

A quick Thomist guide to providence and predestination

Given the posts and ensuing discussion here over the last week or two, I thought it might be useful to link directly to the teaching of Thomas Aquinas on providence, and the subject that springs directly from it in Aquinas’ thought, predestination. Continue reading

Posted in Creation, Theology | 13 Comments

Autonomy and Superposition

Over on BioLogos I’ve been courting controversy again after Ted Davis posted another of his series on John Polkinghorne, in which the latter again promotes the free creation, kenotic God theology so prevalent in theistic evolution now. I critiqued it again, in the hope (after two years) of getting someone to justify it. Continue reading

Posted in Creation, Science, Theology | 10 Comments

Paternoster, providence and power

There’s a running joke in our house, that if I thank my wife for getting me dinner, she replies, “Don’t thank me – thank Tesco.” Sometimes it does indeed seem as if the supermarket chain is taking over the world – though America proved resistant to its might. Tesco not only has a lion’s share of the UK food market, but has exclusive contracts with many food producers, an ability to bleed trade away from every High Street trader to out-of-town stores, a massive vehicle fleet and the distinction of being the largest property company in Europe. But that’s what it takes, it seems, to be able to guarantee ones (necessarily) loyal customers that they’ll be able to get what they want, when they want it. Continue reading

Posted in Creation, Theology | 2 Comments