Escaping the flannelgraph Bible world

Posted on 15/05/2017 by Jon Garvey

Over at “the other place” I’ve been in conversation with Richard Wright about divine action, and one of his points, all too common in the science-faith discussion, is that science has increasingly shown nature to operate through natural causes (and hence the accusations of invoking the “God of the Gaps” in any consideration of design). So divine action is to be sought (at least in Richard’s rather more positive view, compared to some others) in answered prayer, biblical miracles and so on, but not in nature. Continue reading →

Posted in Creation, Science, Theology | Leave a comment

(Testable) hypotheses about a historical Eden

Posted on 11/05/2017 by Jon Garvey

Carrying on the theme of biblical archaeology, Kenneth Kitchen’s book On the Reliability of the Old Testament takes a general overview of the “proto-historic” first 11 chapters of Genesis, but there have been some interesting developments since he wrote it that are worth considering, with regard both to the Flood and to the Eden narrative. Continue reading →

Posted in Adam, Genealogical Adam, History, Science, Theology | 1 Comment

Creative power and oriental potentates

Posted on 08/05/2017 by Jon Garvey

This year’s BioLogos conference was addressed by N T Wright, and his talk was praised by Hump writer Sy Garte on his own website. A clip, basically showing that one might expect an evolutionary process if one sees Christ as the creative Logos of God, appeared later at BioLogos. You can see the four minute clip here.

Continue reading →

Posted in Creation, Theology | Leave a comment

Sodom and aetiological tales

Posted on 04/05/2017 by Jon Garvey

I like to keep tabs on Biblical archaeology from time to time, not only because I wanted to be an archaeologist till my Auntie Dorothy put me off by saying they spend all day down a hole, but because it’s fun to see 19th century mythology about the Bible writers slowly being eroded by a steady trickle of confirmatory evidence (by which you can tell that I’m not sympathetic to the archaeological “minimalists” of the last couple of decades). Continue reading →

Posted in History, Science, Theology | 4 Comments

Intelligent Design, “Cultural Baggage” and the Eye of the Beholder

Posted on 01/05/2017 by Edward Robinson

A frequent theme in BioLogos writing is that Intelligent Design (ID) theory has contaminated the notion of divine design in nature, so much so that some Christians have shied away from even using the word “design.” One can find this notion expressed in remarks of Jim Stump, who wrote a whole column on “reclaiming” the language of design from the alleged damage it had received at the hands of ID people, and in comments by people like Brad Kramer and Casper Hesp. Casper’s latest remark along this line (in a reply to a new poster, Allison) is:

“… the cultural baggage that is linked to the term “design” could be a reason to avoid the term.” Continue reading →

Posted in Edward Robinson, Philosophy, Politics and sociology, Science, Theology | 11 Comments

The two cultures

Posted on 30/04/2017 by Jon Garvey

As C P Snow observed in 1959, there indeed appear to be two cultures at work in our society, one striving for fresh insights into the world, and one bound in dogma and tradition. Let me tell you about two recent conversations that exemplify this sad state of affairs. Continue reading →

Posted in Politics and sociology, Science, Theology | 1 Comment

RNA editing – a squid pro quo?

Posted on 27/04/2017 by Jon Garvey

Empty-headed nautilus

Yet another “unexpected” piece of news on evolution was carried by the Washington Post, though here’s a link to the version in The Independent. As you will see, it concerns the remarkable degree to which cephalopod mollusks like octopi recode their RNA for a number of important functions, including (as the relevant study shows) their nervous system. It appears that their proverbial intelligence is not in the genes, but in their editing (the article contrasts them with the Nautilus, a cephalopod that doesn’t recode, and doesn’t therefore predict election results, escape down pipes and so on). Continue reading →

Posted in Creation, Science | 8 Comments

A centenary of structuralism

Posted on 24/04/2017 by Jon Garvey

Preston Garrison has been sending me a trickle of articles on structuralism since I did a piece (primarily) on the vertebrate pentadactyl limb, let’s see, nearly four years ago. He recently sent me a good Nature piece marking the centenary of D’Arcy Thompson’s book on the mathematical basis of form, On Growth and Form. Continue reading →

Posted in Philosophy, Science | 6 Comments

Teleology and the extended evolutionary synthesis

Posted on 21/04/2017 by Jon Garvey

Jonathan Bartlett is an ID guy, but he has commented here, mainly because I mentioned favourably the conference he organised on Alternatives to Methodological Naturalism, which has now become a book that sounds well worth exploring. He recently did a podcast, available on YouTube, suggesting that the unifying theme behind the various disparate strands that make up what is called the “Extended Evoluionary Synthesis” is teleonomy. Continue reading →

Posted in Creation, Philosophy, Science, Theology | 2 Comments

How did he do that?

Posted on 18/04/2017 by Jon Garvey

The commonest rejoinder to any design argument in nature, you will no doubt have noticed, is “Who’s the designer, then?” Although the ID reply is actually perfectly rational – that inference to design cannot, intrinsically, tell one the nature of the designer in detail – the question is in reality just an over-elaborate, if hackneyed, attempt to show that there is a hidden agenda of religion which, once uncovered, would render design unscientific in principle and, probably, a threat to the body politic.

It’s Catch 22 – stick with methodological naturalism and design is deceitful creationism: mention God in reply to the question and it’s an illegitimate insertion into science. Continue reading →

Posted in Creation, Philosophy, Science, Theology | Leave a comment